(262)377-7230

MYSTERIES ON THE NET

MYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NET
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Complete Mystery List
  • Holiday Murder Mysteries
  • Historical Mysteries
  • Large-Group Mysteries
  • Most-Popular Mysteries
  • Wine and Cheese Mystery
  • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
  • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
  • Wild West Murder Mystery
  • Golf Murder Mystery Party
  • Express Train Mystery
  • Cruise Murder Mystery
  • All-Woman Murder Mystery
  • Al Capone Murder Mystery
  • Pirate Murder Mystery
  • Alaska Murder Mystery
  • Art Gallery Mystery
  • Valentine Day Mystery
  • St. Patrick Day Party
  • St. Patrick Day Mystery
  • Mardi Gras Mystery
  • Easter Murder Mystery
  • 4th of July Mystery
  • Halloween Murder Mystery
  • Halloween Magic Mystery
  • Card Magic Mystery
  • Thanksgiving Mystery
  • Christmas Eve Mystery
  • Christmas Mystery
  • New Year's Eve Mystery
  • 1920s Classic Mystery
  • 1930s Mansion Mystery
  • 1940s Classic Mystery
  • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
  • High-Rise Murder Mystery
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Mystery Party Workshop
  • More
    • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Complete Mystery List
    • Holiday Murder Mysteries
    • Historical Mysteries
    • Large-Group Mysteries
    • Most-Popular Mysteries
    • Wine and Cheese Mystery
    • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
    • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
    • Wild West Murder Mystery
    • Golf Murder Mystery Party
    • Express Train Mystery
    • Cruise Murder Mystery
    • All-Woman Murder Mystery
    • Al Capone Murder Mystery
    • Pirate Murder Mystery
    • Alaska Murder Mystery
    • Art Gallery Mystery
    • Valentine Day Mystery
    • St. Patrick Day Party
    • St. Patrick Day Mystery
    • Mardi Gras Mystery
    • Easter Murder Mystery
    • 4th of July Mystery
    • Halloween Murder Mystery
    • Halloween Magic Mystery
    • Card Magic Mystery
    • Thanksgiving Mystery
    • Christmas Eve Mystery
    • Christmas Mystery
    • New Year's Eve Mystery
    • 1920s Classic Mystery
    • 1930s Mansion Mystery
    • 1940s Classic Mystery
    • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
    • High-Rise Murder Mystery
    • About the Writer
    • Writing Consultation
    • Become an Affiliate
    • Mystery Party Workshop

MYSTERIES ON THE NET

MYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NET

(262)377-7230


  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Complete Mystery List
  • Holiday Murder Mysteries
  • Historical Mysteries
  • Large-Group Mysteries
  • Most-Popular Mysteries
  • Wine and Cheese Mystery
  • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
  • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
  • Wild West Murder Mystery
  • Golf Murder Mystery Party
  • Express Train Mystery
  • Cruise Murder Mystery
  • All-Woman Murder Mystery
  • Al Capone Murder Mystery
  • Pirate Murder Mystery
  • Alaska Murder Mystery
  • Art Gallery Mystery
  • Valentine Day Mystery
  • St. Patrick Day Party
  • St. Patrick Day Mystery
  • Mardi Gras Mystery
  • Easter Murder Mystery
  • 4th of July Mystery
  • Halloween Murder Mystery
  • Halloween Magic Mystery
  • Card Magic Mystery
  • Thanksgiving Mystery
  • Christmas Eve Mystery
  • Christmas Mystery
  • New Year's Eve Mystery
  • 1920s Classic Mystery
  • 1930s Mansion Mystery
  • 1940s Classic Mystery
  • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
  • High-Rise Murder Mystery
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Mystery Party Workshop

Evil Never Dies

Halloween Murder Mystery

He was called Evil-Eyed Emil. When he looked at people with his infamous right eye, so the story went, bad things invariably happened. Townspeople cringed and covered their faces as Emil came near, not daring to look directly into his ominous orb.


And, as he was being driven out of Reaper Junction on Halloween night exactly 100 years ago, Emil vowed to return one day to wreak his vengeance on the mob and its progeny for the way he had been so rudely tossed out.


​That cryptic curse was all but forgotten by today's generation of Reapers who laughed at such nonsense. But, the laughter has stopped. For last night, shockingly and unexpectedly, a local resident staggered into the town square and announced that Emil had been sighted in the woods and, true to his century-old proclamation, someone had been the victim of Emil's anger.


The deceased was Grimsby Graves, the patriarch of a family whose ancestors had helped found Reaper Junction in 1770. ​The Graves' seemed to have had their fingers in every pie that was ever baked in Reaper Junction.  The history books say that it was, in fact, the Graves brothers who had led the torch-lit mob that oversaw Emil's abrupt exit into the stormy night.


So, how then can justice be done? How can someone who is already dead be brought to trial? And, can the court truly find a jury of his peers? Or, will the explanation be less scintillating and more sinister?

The Graves Mansion was avoided by the residents of Reaper Junction.


THE SUSPECTS

Can you identify the killer?

Gregory Graves: Suspect in Murder Mystery "Evil Never Dies."

GREGORY GRAVES

Grimsby Graves's only child. Gregory is a "loner" with few acquaintances and even fewer friends. His time is occupied by his unusual hobby. 

Penelope Crust: Suspect in Murder Mystery "Evil Never Dies."

PENELOPE CRUST

Owner of the Reaper Bakery. Her recipes for Halloween treats have been passed down from generation to generation. No one is quite sure of the ingredients.

BELLA BONES

Mortician and owner of Bones Mortuary. The Bones family has supervised the eternal interment of Reapers for as long as people can remember. 

Jack Lantern: Suspect in Murder Mystery "Evil Never Dies."

JACK LANTERN

Pumpkin farmer. Halloween is his most profitable time of the year as people travel from miles around to purchase the perfect grand gourd from his peculiar patch. 

TODD SWEENEY

Reaper Junction's barber. He's been cutting Reaper hair for years and still uses a straight razor to give his customers the closest possible shaves.

Tara Cardoli: Suspect in Murder Mystery "Evil Never Dies."

TARA CARDOLI

Mystic and fortune teller. Townspeople clandestinely seek her advice. Her predictions have been amazingly accurate. 

Purchase this murder mystery kit for $39.77

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE MYSTERY kit NOW!

THE MURDER MYSTERY KIT includes . . .

Complete instructions

Instructions for the facilitator

Complete instructions

You'll have a step-by-step system for conducting the investigation of the murder of Grimsby Graves from start to the exciting finish. 

Roles for all suspects

Instructions for the facilitator

Complete instructions

The roles will include family backgrounds and recollections of events surrounding the murder with details no one else knows. 

Instructions for the facilitator

Instructions for the facilitator

Instructions for the facilitator

Your facilitator will be in charge using a detailed method for successfully orchestrating the murder mystery investigation. 

​

invitations to the mystery party

invitations to the mystery party

Instructions for the facilitator

Your investigators will receive the details of the party with an introduction to events in Reaper Junction. 

"the reaper harvest"

invitations to the mystery party

Key supporting information

The local newspaper will contain the story of the Graves's death and what is happening in Reaper Junction.

Key supporting information

invitations to the mystery party

Key supporting information

You'll have additional material  such as a sheriff's report that provides more information about the case and cause of death. 

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

The clues will stimulate the investigators to ask questions and can be exchanged or revealed at critical moments. 

The Denouement

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

The "untying" revealed at the end will tie the details together. MOTIVE, MEANS and OPPORTUNITY will point to the guilty party. 

What our customers say

Jodi L. Sorteberg, ​Bakersfield, Ca

Kathy Kennedy, Bristol Kingsport KOA, Blountsville, Tn

Jodi L. Sorteberg, ​Bakersfield, Ca

Five-star review for "Evil Never Dies," downloadable interactive Halloween murder mystery party.

 

The party was a huge success! There was some prep for the event, but the instructions were easy to follow and laid out in such a manner that made planning the event a breeze. Everyone really got into their roles and hearing some of the groups explanations for "who done it" was hilarious!

Kathy Kennedy, Bristol Kingsport KOA, Blountsville, Tn

Jodi L. Sorteberg, ​Bakersfield, Ca

Kathy Kennedy, Bristol Kingsport KOA, Blountsville, Tn

Kathy Kennedy, Bristol Kingsport KOA, Blountsville, Tn

Kathy Kennedy, Bristol Kingsport KOA, Blountsville, Tn

Five-star review for "Evil Never Dies," downloadable interactive Halloween murder mystery party.

 

 I ordered 'Evil Never Dies' from you and it was a big success. So successful, I have had many other KOA inquire about you and your product. Well, I think you are great and will order all of my Murder Mysteries from you. I really think you have the best thing going. Simple, easy and lots of fun. I am going to give out your website to lots of people next week. 

DOWNLOAD THE MYSTERY PARTY KIT FOR $39.77

This mystery is also available as a hard-copy kit in a book format.

The kit can be sent directly to your door. You won't have to copy anything. Simply take apart the book and you'll have everything you need to orchestrate your Murder Mystery Party. 



CLICK ON THE BOOK COVER TO ORDER VIA AMAZON!

contact mysteries on the net

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Mysteries on the Net

PO Box 191, Cedarburg, WI 53012

(262)377-7230

Copyright © 2025 Mysteries on the Net - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Mystery Party Workshop

Are you burning the midnight oil writing a murder mystery?

I can help you produce a best seller that will earn you kudos from your family and sleuthing colleagues!

Find out more

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept