(262)377-7230

MYSTERIES ON THE NET

MYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NET
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Complete Mystery List
  • Holiday Murder Mysteries
  • Historical Mysteries
  • Large-Group Mysteries
  • Most-Popular Mysteries
  • Wine and Cheese Mystery
  • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
  • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
  • Wild West Murder Mystery
  • Golf Murder Mystery Party
  • Express Train Mystery
  • Cruise Murder Mystery
  • All-Woman Murder Mystery
  • Al Capone Murder Mystery
  • Pirate Murder Mystery
  • Alaska Murder Mystery
  • Art Gallery Mystery
  • Valentine Day Mystery
  • St. Patrick Day Party
  • St. Patrick Day Mystery
  • Mardi Gras Mystery
  • Easter Murder Mystery
  • 4th of July Mystery
  • Halloween Murder Mystery
  • Halloween Magic Mystery
  • Card Magic Mystery
  • Thanksgiving Mystery
  • Christmas Eve Mystery
  • Christmas Mystery
  • New Year's Eve Mystery
  • 1920s Classic Mystery
  • 1930s Mansion Mystery
  • 1940s Classic Mystery
  • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
  • High-Rise Murder Mystery
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Mystery Party Workshop
  • More
    • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Complete Mystery List
    • Holiday Murder Mysteries
    • Historical Mysteries
    • Large-Group Mysteries
    • Most-Popular Mysteries
    • Wine and Cheese Mystery
    • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
    • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
    • Wild West Murder Mystery
    • Golf Murder Mystery Party
    • Express Train Mystery
    • Cruise Murder Mystery
    • All-Woman Murder Mystery
    • Al Capone Murder Mystery
    • Pirate Murder Mystery
    • Alaska Murder Mystery
    • Art Gallery Mystery
    • Valentine Day Mystery
    • St. Patrick Day Party
    • St. Patrick Day Mystery
    • Mardi Gras Mystery
    • Easter Murder Mystery
    • 4th of July Mystery
    • Halloween Murder Mystery
    • Halloween Magic Mystery
    • Card Magic Mystery
    • Thanksgiving Mystery
    • Christmas Eve Mystery
    • Christmas Mystery
    • New Year's Eve Mystery
    • 1920s Classic Mystery
    • 1930s Mansion Mystery
    • 1940s Classic Mystery
    • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
    • High-Rise Murder Mystery
    • About the Writer
    • Writing Consultation
    • Become an Affiliate
    • Mystery Party Workshop

MYSTERIES ON THE NET

MYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NETMYSTERIES ON THE NET

(262)377-7230


  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Complete Mystery List
  • Holiday Murder Mysteries
  • Historical Mysteries
  • Large-Group Mysteries
  • Most-Popular Mysteries
  • Wine and Cheese Mystery
  • Hawaiian Murder Mystery
  • Las Vegas Murder Mystery
  • Wild West Murder Mystery
  • Golf Murder Mystery Party
  • Express Train Mystery
  • Cruise Murder Mystery
  • All-Woman Murder Mystery
  • Al Capone Murder Mystery
  • Pirate Murder Mystery
  • Alaska Murder Mystery
  • Art Gallery Mystery
  • Valentine Day Mystery
  • St. Patrick Day Party
  • St. Patrick Day Mystery
  • Mardi Gras Mystery
  • Easter Murder Mystery
  • 4th of July Mystery
  • Halloween Murder Mystery
  • Halloween Magic Mystery
  • Card Magic Mystery
  • Thanksgiving Mystery
  • Christmas Eve Mystery
  • Christmas Mystery
  • New Year's Eve Mystery
  • 1920s Classic Mystery
  • 1930s Mansion Mystery
  • 1940s Classic Mystery
  • 1950s Sitcom Mystery
  • High-Rise Murder Mystery
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Mystery Party Workshop

Murder Plays a Sour Note

New Year’s Eve Murder Mystery

It's New Year's Eve at the Pitz, the city's most famous (or is it infamous?) supper club. The usual mix of customers, some noteworthy and some notorious, decorate the tables that surround the crowded dance floor.


Everyone in the gregarious group of rarified revelers hoists a glass of champagne and readies their noise makers preparing to celebrate the arrival of the year 1955.


As the clock strikes midnight, Lou Gumbardo and his band, The Loyal Geraniums, begin the familiar strains of Auld Lang Syne. The moment has arrived - a new year that promises to continue the post-war boom of the Eisenhower administration.


Suddenly, without warning, the club is in darkness and, amid the rumbling of the assembled guests, three shots ring out. When the lights come on again, it's deadly obvious that the darkened room provided a killer with the opportunity to put a strategic bullet hole into a surprised victim.


Someone had dictated the dastardly demise of an individual whose brief glimpse of the new year proved to be a fatal attraction.

​

As 1955 rolled in, the crowd at The Pitz couldn't wait to hear Sammy Fenetra sing "Auld Lang Syne."

ONE OF THESE INDIVIDUALS IS A VICTIM AND ONE IS A MURDERER

You'll need to purchase the mystery to find out more.

Lou Gumbardo: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

LOU GUMBARDO

Band leader of "The Loyal Geraniums". For the past ten years, his band has been a New Year's Eve fixture at The Pitz.  

Roxy Romano: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

ROXY ROMANO

Owner of The Pitz and former dancer. Roxy has worked hard to make her establishment the number one supper club in the city.

Giovanni Fishi: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

GIOVANNI FISHI

Reputed mob boss. Although he supposedly runs a successful string of dry cleaning shops, its common knowledge that his income is from other sources.

Mary Rose Looney: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

MARY ROSE LOONEY

Songstress. She's been with "The Loyal Geraniums" for the past three years and plans on leaving the band to start her own musical career. 

Sammy Fenetra in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

SAMMY FENETRA

Singer. He and Mary Rose used to be "a thing," but recently the duets have become solos. 

Betty "Boom Boom" Baxter: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

BETTY "BOOM BOOM" BAXTER

Drummer. She's famous for her talent in making percussion come alive. Sometimes she drowns out the rest of the band with her downbeats.

Tony "Ivory" Ivanski: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

TONY "IVORY" IVANSKI

Piano player. He tickles the keys and makes them roar with laughter. Who'd want to shoot him? After all, he's only the piano player. 

Shirley Fedora: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

SHIRLEY FEDORA

Hat check girl. She runs the cloak room and knows what everybody's coat and hat looks like. 

Richmond Dalley: Suspect in New Year’s Eve murder mystery, "Murder Plays a Sour Note."

RICHMOND DALLEY

Mayor of the city. He's been running things for over two decades. If you're not part of his machine, you might as well be invisible. 

Purchase this murder mystery kit for $42.77

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE MYSTERY kit NOW!

THE MURDER MYSTERY KIT includes . . .

Complete instructions

Instructions for the facilitator

Complete instructions

You'll have a step-by-step system for conducting the investigation of the New Year's Eve celebration from start to the exciting finish. 

Roles for all suspects

Instructions for the facilitator

Complete instructions

The roles will include family backgrounds and recollections of important events with details no one else knows. 

Instructions for the facilitator

Instructions for the facilitator

Instructions for the facilitator

Your facilitator will be in charge using a detailed method for successfully orchestrating the mystery investigation. 

​

invitations to the mystery party

invitations to the mystery party

Instructions for the facilitator

Your investigators will receive the details of the party with an introduction to the festivities at The Pitz night club. 

"The windy city gust"

invitations to the mystery party

Key supporting information

The New Year's Eve edition of the newspaper will contain information about what is planned for The Pitz's celebration.

Key supporting information

invitations to the mystery party

Key supporting information

You'll have additional material  such as a police report that provides more information about the case. 

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

The clues will stimulate the investigators to ask questions and can be exchanged or revealed at critical moments. 

The Denouement

A series of written clues

A series of written clues

The "untying" revealed at the end will tie the details together. MOTIVE, MEANS and OPPORTUNITY will point to the guilty party. 

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

Irma Netting, Luling, La

Barbara Spiri, Founder and Director ​Penn Hills Musical Alumni, ​Pittsburgh, PA

Marve Stockert, EVP, Falcon Innovations, Chicago, Il

Five-star review of "Murder Plays a Sour Note," downloadable New Year Eve murder mystery party game.

We played "Murder Plays a Sour Note" last night and we all had an incredible time! It was so much fun that we can't wait to do another one. Thanks for everything you do, Jack. It's very cool that you can share your creativity with us like you do!
 

Marve Stockert, EVP, Falcon Innovations, Chicago, Il

Barbara Spiri, Founder and Director ​Penn Hills Musical Alumni, ​Pittsburgh, PA

Marve Stockert, EVP, Falcon Innovations, Chicago, Il

Five-star review of "Murder Plays a Sour Note," downloadable New Year Eve murder mystery party game.

 It was so much fun and everyone got into their characters. It was a blast. The average group was 70 and we partied till 1am. With everyone talking about the mystery and sharing laughs as the ball dropped. All 17 people would recommend the murder mystery for a New Year’s Eve Party. Thanks for a good time. We will be doing more.

Barbara Spiri, Founder and Director ​Penn Hills Musical Alumni, ​Pittsburgh, PA

Barbara Spiri, Founder and Director ​Penn Hills Musical Alumni, ​Pittsburgh, PA

Barbara Spiri, Founder and Director ​Penn Hills Musical Alumni, ​Pittsburgh, PA

Five-star review of "Murder Plays a Sour Note," downloadable New Year Eve murder mystery party game.

We turned my house into the Pitz (lighted sign and all) for New Years and did it at a local church on a larger scale that spring. It was well received. Keep up the good writing :)

​

DOWNLOAD THE MYSTERY party KIT FOR $42.77!

This mystery is also available as a hard-copy kit in a book format.

The kit can be sent directly to your door. You won't have to copy anything. Simply take apart the book and you'll have everything you need to orchestrate your Murder Mystery Party. 



CLICK ON THE BOOK COVER TO ORDER VIA AMAZON!

Contact mysteries on the net

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Mysteries on the Net

PO Box 191, Cedarburg, WI 53012

(262)377-7230

Copyright © 2025 Mysteries on the Net - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • About the Writer
  • Writing Consultation
  • Mystery Party Workshop

Are you burning the midnight oil writing a murder mystery?

I can help you produce a best seller that will earn you kudos from your family and sleuthing colleagues!

Find out more

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept